Weekend Watch: Opinions, picks on biggest matchups
All eyes will be on the two hottest teams in baseball, the Milwaukee Brewers and Chicago Cubs, tangling at Wrigley Field, but there are plenty of other matchups worth watching this weekend. Here’s what we’re most looking forward to.
Matz: Striking distance? Sure. Beating out the Dodgers in the National League West seems like a pipe dream, but I see no reason why the D-backs can’t hang with the other wild-card wannabes. Their run differential (plus-17 entering Thursday) says their early-season success is legit, and the front of the rotation (Zack Greinke, Robbie Ray and Luke Weaver) is solid. If they can get any kind of contribution down the stretch from Taijuan Walker, who’s expected back from Tommy John surgery around midseason, it would go a long way toward upping their postseason odds (currently at 21 percent, per FanGraphs). All that said, I still think they will come up short in the end.
Brewers at Cubs, Fri., 2:20 p.m. (ESPN+) — Another weekend, another huge NL Central series at Wrigley.
Yankees at Rays, Fri., 7 p.m. — The top two teams in the AL East lock up at Yankee Stadium South.
Braves at Diamondbacks, Sat., 8:10 p.m. — Which “A” logo is better: Atlanta’s or Arizona’s? We’ll take the forked tongue in a runaway.
Nationals at Dodgers, Sat., 9:10 p.m. — Max Scherzer vs. Walker Buehler, a matchup of Cy Young winners past and future?
Marlins at Mets, Sun., 1:10 p.m. — You know about Jacob deGrom, but how about Miami starter Caleb Smith? His 0.89 WHIP is top 10 in MLB.
Brewers at Cubs, Sun., 7 p.m. (ESPN) — The finale of what could be the series of the early season.
Miller: Here’s something wild: Carson Kelly has a higher OPS than Paul Goldschmidt, and Luke Weaver has a better ERA than Patrick Corbin, so the Diamondbacks’ offseason step back (which included trading Goldie for Kelly and Weaver, and letting Corbin leave as a free agent) hasn’t actually hurt them yet. Yet, I said. Yet! I don’t really buy this offense — they’ve scored the third-most runs in the NL, and nearly every hitter is outhitting his preseason projections — but the NL really hasn’t done enough to knock any teams out of striking distance yet. A whopping 12 teams — including the three division leaders — currently have wild-card odds between 5 and 30 percent, according to the Baseball Prospectus.
Schoenfield: Arizona’s front office certainly did a creditable job of reloading without completely tearing everything down (although, let’s be honest, if they could have traded Greinke’s contract, they probably would have). I think it all depends on where the playoffs picture sits. It’s possible that, in a crowded NL field, 84 to 86 wins puts you in the running for at least a wild card. In that case, Arizona may stick around. One advantage is that if the Giants are bad, the Rockies are an under-.500 team and the Padres are merely a fluke at the moment, the NL West could be the weakest of the three divisions.
Matz: The Giants have actually been swinging it well lately, plus they just faced Castillo on Sunday. So I say no-go on the no-no there. Berrios against the Tigers is more likely, but not as likely as JdG no-hitting the Fish. The Mets’ ace dominated them earlier this season (7 IP, 3 H, 0 ER, 14 K), and that was way back when Miami’s offense was “good.” Lately, the Marlins’ offense has been brutal (no quotes necessary). They’re prime no-hit material.
The Oakland A’s journeyman joined rare company in throwing his second career no-no, working harder than most to get there.
David Schoenfield
Miller: Castillo took a no-hitter into the sixth against the Giants on Sunday, and while Eddie is right that familiarity benefits the offense, Castillo is my pick. He’s allowing 5.36 hits per nine, which — if he could maintain it all season — would be the fifth-lowest rate in history, behind a couple of Nolan Ryan joints.
Schoenfield: I’ll go with deGrom versus the Fish. He seems past that little blip where he was hittable and back to a 2018 level. Plus, the Fish … dear lord, this is one of the worst offenses I’ve ever seen. Derek Jeter is unhappy with this start? DEREK, YOU BUILT THIS TEAM AND IT’S PRETTY MUCH PLAYING TO ITS LEVEL OF TALENT. Anyway, “Fish” isn’t even an appropriate nickname anymore. I’d say “Minnows” works better.
Matz: MVP voters these days pay more and more attention to WAR. As good as Baez is, his low on-base numbers damage his WAR potential, which in turn hurts his MVP viability. So it’s either Belly or Yelly. I’ll give the edge to the guy who has the better chance of staying healthy. That’d be the guy who’s four years younger and didn’t just miss a week with back spasms (hint: rhymes with Schmody Schmellinger).
How Christian Yelich became a future Hall of Famer in 400 plate appearances.
Sam Miller
Miller: To make the case for Baez: He finished second in voting last year, with an OPS more than 100 points lower than he has now. As Eddie says, the MVP award has become (with some caveats) mostly a WAR award, and Baez gets a huge WAR boost for playing shortstop while the others are manning corners. And while all three do incredible things, Baez’s best moments stick in your visual memory longer, simply because of the highly creative, high-torque style of play he has. Now, all that said: Bellinger is the leader in the race right now, and Yelich is probably the actual best player of the three, so he’s the most likely to lead at the end. Handicapping ’em, Yelich > Bellinger > Baez.
Schoenfield: I’ll admit that I didn’t expect Baez to do this again, believing pitchers would do a better job of figuring out his inability to control the strike zone. Yet here he is with 44 strikeouts and nine walks and putting up even bigger numbers. He has the third-highest chase rate in the majors among regulars and one of the highest swing-and-miss rates. He’s an absolute freak. Do not attempt his approach at your local Little League field, kids. Anyway, he’ll play more second base with Addison Russell back, which could hurt him in MVP voting or help him (extra credit for his versatility). I’ll go Bellinger > Yelich > Baez.
Matz: Watching Mike Trout in person. I don’t get to see a whole lot of Trout up close, but this weekend he and the Angels visit Camden Yards. In related news, I live in Baltimore. So, yay.
Miller: I’ve got a pet interest in a very obscure sort of record — the most strikeouts by a pitcher over nine innings — so I’m watching Josh Hader, who has struck out 25 batters over his past nine innings.
Schoenfield: The Cubs are hot. The Brewers are hot. This feels like the series of the weekend. Plus, we can see if Baez can touch Hader.
Matz: The numbers say that they should give up a combined seven hits over 13 innings. Or something like that. But both guys are due for a clunker. I’ll take the over.
Miller: The Rays will have 9.5 hits when Boone comes out to get German in the fourth. Glasnow could throw a no-hitter, but I’m not banking on it. Over.
Schoenfield: I’m still kicking myself for not drafting German in my keeper fantasy league a few years ago. I liked his minor league numbers and thought he had a chance to start even if most projected him as a future reliever. Well, after struggling last year (5.57 ERA), he got another opportunity because of injuries in the rotation and he’s ran with it. Anyway, great matchup and I like to be positive around here, so I’ll go under.
Matz: The M’s lead the majors in whiffs, but not whiff rate (they’re ninth). Still, they’re facing a Red Sox staff that just tallied 22 strikeouts in a single game. Sure it was against the Orioles, and yes it took 12 innings. But still … 22 punchies!!! I’ll have the over, garcon.
Miller: Heck, the American League average this year is a strikeout per inning — an all-time high — so all I need is one game to go 10 innings for this to be a stone-cold certainty. Over.
Schoenfield: Chris Sale won’t start in this series, but you know all those right-handed hitters in the Mariners lineup will be swinging from their heels when they see the Green Monster. Wait, they always swing from their heels. Is that even a saying anymore? Probably not. May have dated myself there. Over.
Matz: Irresistible force vs. immovable object. Both teams are smokin’ hot. But if I have to pick one pitcher to win one game — whether it’s an October wild card or a May whatever — I’m taking Jon Lester over Jhoulys Chacin. Cubs win. Cubs win. Cubs win.
Miller: Can’t you ask me this after Saturday’s game, when I’ll know how many innings Hader has thrown in the first two games of the series? If he’s fresh and fully available, I’ll pick the Brewers, with Hader getting an eight-out save (and striking out eight).
Schoenfield: Yelich enters the weekend with 15 home runs at home and one on the road. There are two ways to look at this: He’s due to start hitting more home runs on the road, or the Brewers are stealing signs at home. This game is at Wrigley. But if I pick against the Brewers, I’m insinuating the Brewers are stealing signs and there is no evidence that is the case. So I’ll go with the Brewers … and Yelich homers.
Each week, we ask our panelists to choose one hitter they think will hit the most home runs and one pitcher they think will record the most strikeouts in the coming weekend. Panelists can pick a player only once for the season. We’ll keep a running tally — and invite you to play along at home.
Matz: Trevor Story
Miller: Mike Trout
Schoenfield: Christian Yelich
Matz: Jacob deGrom
Miller: Noah Syndergaard
Schoenfield: Oh, just realized it’s Max Scherzer versus Walker Buehler on Saturday. That’s a fun one. Nationals have the fourth-highest K rate, so let’s go with Buehler at home.