Batongbacal says delay in South China Sea COC talks ‘not unexpected’; Teodoro wary of China’s ‘good faith’
Fisherfolk on small bancas join volunteers from the Atin Ito Coalition and members of the media as they prepare to depart from Matalbis Port in Masinloc, Zambales, for the second civilian resupply mission to the West Philippine Sea on May 15, 2024. Maria Tan, ABS-CBN News/FileMANILA — The delay in concluding negotiations for a Code of Conduct (COC) in the South China Sea was not unexpected, according to University of the Philippines Institute for Maritime Affairs and the Law of the Sea Director Professor Jay Batongbacal.
Batongbacal said he had earlier anticipated that negotiations might not be completed this year, noting that the parties would likely continue grappling with the same contentious issues when talks resume under Singapore’s chairmanship of ASEAN in 2027.
“It’s not unexpected. And in fact, in previous months, when I was asked what I thought about the prospects, I always said that there’s a big chance it will not be finished,” Batongbacal said during the Manila Dialogue on the South China Sea in Parañaque City.
“I would expect that ASEAN will continue to try to move the process forward next year, but the same obstacles will still be the same. The milestone issues and threshold issues—the ones that are most difficult to resolve—will still be there,” he added.
Batongbacal also noted that even officials from other ASEAN member states were aware of the possibility that negotiations would extend beyond this year.
Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro on Sunday announced that negotiations for the COC would continue into 2027 under Singapore’s ASEAN chairmanship, with nearly 80% of the draft having reached provisional agreement among the parties.
Lazaro said the parties had agreed to continue working toward an effective and substantive agreement at the earliest possible time.
Another maritime security and international relations expert, Dr. Renato De Castro, pointed out that the remaining provisions could prove particularly difficult to settle.
“Twenty percent is actually the most complicated part of the COC,” De Castro said.
Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro Jr., meanwhile, said he personally will not rely on China’s good faith in implementing the proposed agreement.
“To see is to believe and I will reserve my opinion on trust. I am paid not to rely on the good faith of an adversary. If I rely on the good faith of an adversary in my job as defense secretary, then they might as well find somebody else,” Teodoro said when asked whether he trusts China to uphold the COC once it is finalized.
Teodoro also emphasized that the proposed agreement is between ASEAN and China, and not a bilateral arrangement between the Philippines and China.
In contrast, Philippine Coast Guard spokesperson for the West Philippine Sea Rear Admiral Jay Tarriela expressed optimism that the long-awaited COC would eventually be realized.
“I am optimistic it will be realized in the coming years. But for now, we will have to wait and see,” Tarriela said.
The COC is intended to establish a framework for managing tensions and promoting cooperation in the South China Sea, where overlapping maritime claims and continuing incidents involving claimant states have raised concerns over regional stability.
The Philippines has maintained that any agreement must be consistent with international law, particularly the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS), and must not undermine the 2016 South China Sea Arbitral Award.