Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Thinking Port

Another port for thinking people…

ABS-CBNNewsPhilippines

No need to file rebuttal evidence yet in VP Duterte trial — prosecution

Private counsel for the prosecution Atty. Erwin Matib examines Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) Chief of Staff Atty. Anne Loraine Garcia-Marquez during the 36th day of Duterte’s impeachment trial at the Senate of the Philippines in Pasay City on Thursday, October 8, 2026. Maria Tan, ABS-CBN NewsMANILA — The prosecution has yet to see the need to file any rebuttal evidence in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial, according to House prosecution counsel Atty. Benjamin Tolosa Jr.

“When we rested our case, tiwala kami doon sa nabuo namin na kaso. And that remains until now. So we don’t see the need to ask that we be allowed to present rebuttal evidence,” Tolosa told the media.

He said the prosecution welcomes the defense witnesses’ statements, particularly pointing to Island Garden City of Samal Assessor Engineer John Kenneth Enumerables, “who admitted that he cannot say with absolute certainty na isa nga itong property na titled na identified ng Register of Deeds of Samal doon sa nakadeklara sa Statement of Assets, Liabilities, and Net Worth (SALN).”

Enumerables, who took the witness stand on November 10, initially testified that the property in his documents is the same as that declared in Duterte’s SALNs. 

He later failed to provide a conclusive statement when the prosecution and senator-judges further questioned him over conflicting barangay names.

‘PARANG WEAKNESSES’

House prosecutor Rep. Terry Ridon, meanwhile, expressed doubts the next set of defense witnesses will be able to explain the transactions flagged by the Anti-Money Laundering Council, even likening them to “weaknesses.”

Among those expected to testify this week is a lawyer who will talk about matters related to the Anti-Money Laundering Act, according to Tolosa.

“Pareho lang din naman ho ‘yung pagtingin ho namin dito sa next set of witnesses. Parang weaknesses pa rin ‘yun pong isasalang po ng depensa. Kasi again, even if you have an AML expert, I don’t think it will ever contradict ‘yun pong findings ng actual Anti-Money Laundering Council, no?” Ridon asked.

“I think they will try to showcase na mayroon ho nga — wala namang actual conclusivity ‘yun pong findings ng Anti-Money Laundering Council irrespective of whichever document it is,” he added.

Ridon believes the defense will try to show that the transactions supposedly linked to Duterte and her husband do not raise red flags.

“Tingin ko susubukan po nilang magpaliwanag na wala naman dapat problema itong transaksiyon na umaabot po ng P4.4 billion na nakapangalan po sa mag-asawang Duterte-Carpio. Tingin ko susubukan po nilang ipakita na ito po ay paggalaw lamang ng pera at hindi po ito pag-reflect ng kayamanan,” Ridon told reporters.

“Hindi ho tayo aabot ng 4.4 billion in financial volume, in financial transactions, kung wala pong pinagmumulang malaking pera to begin with,” he added.

Ridon shares the view of lead House prosecutor Rep. Gerville Luistro that the testimonies of the defense witnesses presented last week were as “non-explosive” as a “watusi”.

“Sinusuportahan po natin ‘yung pagtingin ni Chairperson Luistro na wala tayong nakitang pasabog, wala tayong nakitang kahit ano. Kahit nga kwitis, wala po tayong nakita… ‘Yun pong expectation ng senator-judges is something that is warranted na talagang dapat ho pag-usapan po ‘yun pong malalaking mga amounts na tingin ho namin, na-establish noon pong prosecution evidence nung pong nakaraan,” Ridon said.

RELATED VIDEO:

Leave a Reply