Defense challenges report alleging Duterte’s P817-M undeclared wealth
MANILA — The defense’s expert witness on Thursday provided legal opinions on the methodology and findings of a prosecution witness who claimed Vice President Sara Duterte has accumulated a total of P817 million in undeclared wealth.
Financial forensic analyst Alexander Cabrera previously testified that Duterte and his husband, Manases Carpio, had amassed a total of P817.87 million in undeclared wealth from 2022 to 2025, based on discrepancies between her asset declarations, records from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR), and banks.
Defense witness Rainer Dela Fuente, a certified public accountant and lawyer who previously worked for the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC), said Cabrera piercing the corporate veil of the companies linked to Duterte and Carpio raises questions about the reliability of his report.
Dela Fuente said the corporate veil may be pierced only through a legal decision that has undergone due process, noting its three grounds — public purpose, the corporation’s commission of fraud, and being used as an alter ego.
Asked by defense counsel Mark Vinluan about the reliability of Cabrera’s report, Dela Fuente said: “It questions the assumptions made. Nagkakaroon ng duda doon sa mga assumptions and computations made.”
He said without piercing the corporate veil, only the companies’ dividends may be attributed to the affiliated individuals.
Vinluan, upon asking the witness about the findings’ reliability, said the numbers Cabrera used were “quite inaccurate,” which immediately prompted an objection from House prosecutor Chel Diokno.
Dela Fuente meanwhile said: “It would depend on the application of wisdom ng ating Senate impeachment court. If this is reliable or not, kayo na po ang nakaka-appreciate doon sa mga ebidensiyang ipinresenta.”
Dela Fuente also commented on Cabrera’s supposed use of receipts to verify that five fast food restaurant Jollibee branches in Davao City were under Gencorp Industries Inc. — which Duterte declared a business interest in. Gencorp did not name Duterte in any of its SEC documents.
“Actually, Your Honor, napapakunot ako ng noo kanina doon sa resibo. We don’t do this in financial investigations,” he said, noting that receipts may be altered by artificial intelligence.
He said the information can instead be verified by official SEC documents.
The witness also testified that Cabrera’s report attributing 20 percent of the supposed P175 million initial franchise cost for the five Jollibee branches to Duterte was only based on “desktop research” and should have been complemented by onsite report, including interviews with witnesses, walkthroughs and verification of what transpired in the paper review.
As for the insurances flagged by the prosecution, Dela Fuente testified that Duterte and Carpio were co-owners and that the total costs should not be attributed to the vice president alone.
Meanwhile, the anti-money laundering compliance practitioner noted that return of capital and income are different.
Gencorp’s counsel Suzette Balucanag-Punay earlier testified that Duterte received P2.1 million from the company as a “return of capital”, contrary to Cabrera’s earlier statement that the vice president received a total of P212,629,718.
Vinluan noted Cabrera was “around 100x off or mali,” which Diokno also objected to.
The defense asked Dela Fuente: “How do you characterize a report that uses conjectures?”
“If it concerns financial investigations, hindi ho lang base sa conjectures. Dapat po ito ay may facts, base sa aktuwal na nangyari,” said Dela Fuente.
Asked by Vinluan about the report’s value in AMLC, Dela Fuente also noted that he “does not see the need of outsourcing these information,” as the council has the mandate to investigate a public official’s wealth.
He said the AMLC does not rely on third party analysts and that it “is not bound to admit, rebut or suspend activities pending the review of private documents.”
Vinluan confirmed that Dela Fuente was not furnished with the report of Cabrera, the forensic financial analyst.
Cabrera had described his estimate as conservative and said the amount could reach P1.5 billion under broader assumptions.
Vinluan said the defense team opted to ask Dela Fuente about “actual portions” of the report and seek his “general comments” about it.
Senator-judge Joel Villanueva interjected and said that if the defense, through Dela Fuente, sought to refute Cabrera’s findings, he should have read the report prior to testifying.
The defense counsel explained that his team wanted to ask questions to Dela Fuente in open court and that they did not want to have a prior correspondence with the witness.
Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo echoed Villanueva’s sentiment, saying Dela Fuente having read the financial report in full would have allowed him to offer “intelligent” and “well-informed” assessment of the analysis.
During cross-examination by prosecutor Chel Diokno, Dela Fuente said that he conducted research, which included reading and watching the news, as he had “no access” to Cabrera’s report.
Tulfo also criticized the defense’s broad questions to Dela Fuente, which included queries related to legal, constitutional as well as commerce and trade.
Vinluan said that “part of our offer is for the witness to testify in other relevant matters, and we deem that these are all relevant matters.”