Ex-AMLC investigator testifies in Sara Duterte impeachment trial
The defense in Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial questioned the reliability of the prosecution’s financial investigation, arguing that its findings were based on figures that were not necessarily attributable to the Vice President.
On Day 44 of the trial, the defense presented former Anti-Money Laundering Council investigator Rainer Dela Fuente as its seventh witness.
Through Dela Fuente’s testimony, the defense argued that declaring business and financial interests in Statements of Assets, Liabilities and Net Worth, or SALNs, does not in itself establish wrongdoing.
Defense counsel Mark Vinluan cited the SALNs of former vice president Leni Robredo and President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., which also listed business and financial interests.
Dela Fuente said such information would ordinarily be noted by a financial investigator but would not, by itself, be considered suspicious.
The defense also pointed to the growth in Marcos’ declared wealth during his time in office.
The Constitution prohibits the President, Vice President, members of the Cabinet, and other specified high-ranking officials from holding other offices or employment, practicing a profession, or engaging in business during their tenure, subject to certain exceptions.
The defense likewise sought to cast doubt on allegations of unexplained wealth by presenting a hypothetical scenario involving a public official and a private citizen spouse.
Dela Fuente said that if the couple’s combined lawful income, on which proper taxes had been paid, accounted for their accumulated wealth, this would weaken the argument that they had unexplained income.
The defense also maintained that the income and assets of corporations allegedly associated with the Duterte-Carpio family should not automatically be attributed to the couple.
Dela Fuente said corporate assets should remain separate unless there were grounds to pierce the corporate veil. He added that only amounts actually received by the individuals, such as salaries or dividends, could be attributed to them.
This, the defense argued, undermined the findings of prosecution expert witness Alexander Cabrera, whose financial report allegedly placed the Duterte couple’s wealth at more than 800 million pesos.
Dela Fuente said the use of assumed annual declarations, rather than verified actual figures, weakened the reliability of the report.
The defense also questioned the public disclosure of Anti-Money Laundering Council information, arguing that these reports are confidential because they serve as investigative leads and require further verification by law enforcement agencies.
Dela Fuente explained that AMLC intelligence reports are intended for case-building and information gathering, not as direct evidence or grounds for coercive action.
He warned that releasing such information publicly without a court order could compromise the safety and security of account holders.
The defense further argued that access to AMLC information is restricted to courts and appropriate government agencies, and that the rights of account holders must still be respected.
But House prosecutor Chel Diokno questioned the relevance of Dela Fuente’s testimony, saying the issues before the impeachment court concern unexplained wealth, non-disclosure in SALNs, and participation in business.
Diokno argued that the witness had not demonstrated expertise directly relevant to these matters.
Vinluan countered that the prosecution had presented its own AMLC witness and financial expert, giving the defense the prerogative to present an expert of its own.
Much of the court’s time, however, was spent on the defense’s presentation of video clips featuring three personalities who had previously raised concerns about the possible political use of government investigative agencies.
The first clip featured the late Senator Miriam Defensor-Santiago, who served as a senator-judge during the impeachment trial of former chief justice Renato Corona.
In the recording, Santiago said the prosecution had a duty, not merely a privilege, to present evidence in support of its articles of impeachment.
Senator-judge Erwin Tulfo questioned the relevance of the clip, saying the proceedings were beginning to resemble a movie presentation. Senator-judge Panfilo Lacson also said he could not see the significance of Santiago’s opinion in the earlier impeachment trial.
Senator-judge Alan Peter Cayetano, meanwhile, pointed out that the prosecution had been given considerable time to present its evidence, adding that the issue of alleged ill-gotten wealth remained part of the current impeachment proceedings.
The defense next played a clip of the late former chief justice Renato Corona, who claimed that various government agencies, including the Bureau of Internal Revenue, Land Registration Authority, AMLC, and Office of the Ombudsman, had been mobilized against him and his family during his impeachment.
But Senator-judge Raffy Tulfo reminded the defense that Corona was ultimately impeached over alleged dishonesty in his SALN.
Diokno also questioned the relevance of Corona’s statements, describing them as an appeal to emotion that had no place in the impeachment trial.
The final clip featured former president Rodrigo Duterte, who defended his right to speak freely in a democracy and questioned the basis for actions taken against him.
Through the video presentations, the defense maintained that government investigative agencies, particularly the AMLC, could be used as political weapons.
The prosecution, however, continued to insist that the impeachment case against Vice President Duterte is not a money laundering trial, but centers on allegations of unexplained wealth, SALN violations, and prohibited business interests. – ANC, The World Tonight, November 19, 2026