Tarriela, Chinese academic clash over Ayungin Shoal during Manila Dialogue
This aerial photograph taken from a military aircraft shows the dilapidated Sierra Madre ship of the Philippine Navy anchored near Ayungin shoal (Second Thomas Shoal) with Philippine soldiers on-board to secure the perimeter in the Spratly group of islands in the South China Sea, west of Palawan, on May 11, 2015. Ritchie B. Tongo, Pool/AFPMANILA — A brief but heated exchange erupted during the Manila Dialogue on the South China Sea on Monday after a Chinese academic claimed that the Philippines had been illegally occupying Ayungin Shoal, also known as Second Thomas Shoal, for nearly three decades.
Dr. Zheng Zhihua of Shanghai Jiao Tong University argued that China had exercised restraint despite what he described as the Philippines’ occupation of Chinese territory, adding that China had only resorted to water cannons to defend its territorial integrity.
“China only uses water cannon. As a bigger power, I think if other countries occupy your land territory, you only use water cannon to defend your territorial integrity,” Zheng said.
Philippine Coast Guard spokesperson for the West Philippine Sea Rear Adm. Jay Tarriela immediately challenged the claim, stressing that China has no territorial jurisdiction over Ayungin Shoal.
“The last time I checked, Second Thomas Shoal is only 125 nautical miles from [Palawan]. And it is within our exclusive economic zone (EEZ), not China’s,” Tarriela said.
Zheng pushed back, questioning the Philippines’ characterization of the shoal as part of its EEZ and arguing that Manila invoked its EEZ claims selectively.
The BRP Sierra Madre, a commissioned Philippine Navy vessel, has been grounded at Ayungin Shoal since 1999 and serves as a permanent outpost for Filipino military personnel.
Under the 2016 arbitral ruling, Ayungin Shoal is a low-tide elevation within the Philippines’ 200-nautical-mile EEZ and continental shelf. The tribunal ruled that Beijing’s historic-rights claims in the South China Sea have no legal basis under UNCLOS.