Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Thinking Port

Another port for thinking people…

ABS-CBNNewsPhilippines

Jay Tarriela likens states violating international law to Voldemort

Philippine Coast Guard spokesperson Commodore Jay Tarriela during a joint NTF-WPS press conference at the PCG Office in Manila on March 6, 2024. Jonathan Cellona, ABS-CBN News/File

MANILA — Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) spokesperson for the West Philippine Sea Rear Admiral Jay Tarriela on Tuesday likened countries that violate international law to Voldemort, the villain in the Harry Potter series known as “He Who Must Not Be Named,” drawing a pointed response from a Chinese academic who said that “one’s Voldemort might be another’s Dumbledore.”

During a roundtable discussion at the Manila Dialogue on the South China Sea in Parañaque City, Tarriela explained how the Philippine government’s transparency initiative in the West Philippine Sea has encouraged the international community to become more vocal in calling out countries responsible for aggressive and coercive actions in the waters.

“Before we started the transparency, the international community who are friends, partners, and allies, and protector of the rules-based order, they all consider this external actor as Voldemort in Harry Potter,” Tarriela said.

“They would only say the Embassy of [a country] is concerned about the tensions happening in the South China Sea. They won’t even name that external actor. They won’t even name the incidents that are happening, whether it’s a military-grade laser or water cannoning,” he added.

The official said the Philippine government’s transparency efforts have since encouraged governments of other countries to issue more direct statements identifying the incidents and the states involved.

“Right now, the international community no longer hesitates to call out who is Voldemort, who is the aggressor, who is the victim, and who is the bully,” Tarriela said.

However, Tarriela stressed that his Voldemort analogy was not exclusively directed at a particular country.

“Whenever I refer to Voldemort, this is a state actor who chooses not to adhere to international law. So, this is not just ultimately dedicated to one particular state. Those who violate international law [are] Voldemort,” he said.

 
‘ONE’S VOLDEMORT MIGHT BE ANOTHER’S DUMBLEDORE’
 

Dr. Sophie Wushuang Yi of Beijing’s Grandview Institution reacted to Tarriela’s Harry Potter analogy, saying that the concepts of justice and fairness can be interpreted according to one’s perspective.

Yi, who described herself as a Harry Potter fan, said she was saddened by the comparison.

“As I said in my opening, one country’s defense is another’s offense,” Yi argued.

“We have our own interpretations of the definitions of justice. You have your own interpretations. So, one’s Voldemort is perhaps one’s, you know, true leader—Dumbledore,” she further said.

Dumbledore, the Hogwarts headmaster in the Harry Potter series, is portrayed as one of the story’s principal defenders against Voldemort.

Yi added that a deeper understanding of the circumstances surrounding the South China Sea disputes was necessary.

The Philippine government launched the transparency initiative in February 2023, after a China Coast Guard vessel directed a military-grade laser at the PCG’s BRP Malapascua near Ayungin Shoal, also known as Second Thomas Shoal.

According to Tarriela, the initiative has three objectives: raising awareness among Filipinos about developments in the West Philippine Sea, informing the international community about violations of international law, and countering misinformation and fake news surrounding maritime incidents.

RELATED VIDEO:

Leave a Reply