Friday, November 20, 2026

Thinking Port

Another port for thinking people…

ABS-CBNNewsPhilippines

Senator-judges question Duterte defense witness over financial report

Several senator-judges clashed over the defense panel’s line of questioning and the testimony of its seventh witness, former Anti-Money Laundering Council investigator and certified public accountant Rainer Dela Fuente, during the 44th day of Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial.

Senators Raffy Tulfo and Erwin Tulfo questioned Dela Fuente’s assessment of a forensic financial report on Duterte’s alleged unexplained wealth, saying he appeared to be casting doubt on the findings without having studied the documents behind them.

Raffy Tulfo questioned how Dela Fuente could immediately identify supposed errors in the report without first reading or analyzing it.

The senator-judge stressed that an intelligent witness should study the material presented to him, conduct research, and analyze the information before offering an assessment.

Erwin Tulfo, meanwhile, said the witness’s statements appeared theoretical and could not be effectively challenged using documented financial intelligence if he had not examined the relevant records.

He also urged the defense to present stronger witnesses who could directly rebut the prosecution’s claims.

However, not all senator-judges agreed with the criticism.

Senator Imee Marcos reminded the chamber that Lady Justice is blindfolded, stressing that people should be treated equally under the law regardless of their personalities or the documents involved.

Senator Camille Villar also defended the witness, saying Dela Fuente could answer questions based on universal principles even without seeing the specific documents. She added that the defense’s expert witness should be given sufficient time to respond.

The defense panel later explained that it deliberately withheld a copy of the forensic financial report from Dela Fuente to preserve his independence.

Defense spokesperson Atty. Michael Poa said the decision was meant to ensure that witnesses would not be accused of being coached by the defense.

Meanwhile, Duterte spokesperson Atty. Paolo Panelo accused some senator-judges of acting like prosecutors instead of impartial members of the impeachment court.

Panelo said it was not the job of senator-judges to perform the prosecution’s work, but rather to allow the prosecution to establish its case.

Poa, however, said the defense respected the senator-judges’ authority to ask questions and express their views, even if their positions differed from those of the defense.

Dela Fuente’s qualifications and work history also came under scrutiny during the proceedings.

His résumé showed that he had worked for several government agencies but had not stayed for long periods in some of them.

Dela Fuente explained that he had been a working student who chose to prioritize his education. He also said he left the Anti-Money Laundering Council because of security concerns raised by his family.

He maintained that his competence and experience should not be measured by the number of years he had worked in a particular field, but by the quality of his work.

The defense’s line of questioning also drew criticism from some senator-judges after one of Duterte’s lawyers, Atty. Mark Vinluan, asked Dela Fuente about the constitutional principle of modest living and the propriety of a public official who claims to fight poverty owning a luxury vehicle worth around 13.5 million pesos.

Dela Fuente declined to directly answer the hypothetical question.

Senator Raffy Tulfo questioned whether the witness was being expected to answer practically every topic raised by the defense, even joking about the apparent focus on a Mercedes-Benz G-Wagon.

Poa later explained that the question was intended to establish the issue of modest living, which had emerged during the proceedings.

Meanwhile, Dela Fuente raised concerns over the possible violation of confidentiality laws after the prosecution provided financial forensic expert Alexander Cabrera with copies of Duterte’s bank transactions, investments, and other financial records for his report on her alleged unexplained wealth.

But during questioning by Senator Joel Villanueva, Dela Fuente acknowledged that payments received after an investment’s recorded capital had been fully repaid could potentially be classified as income, depending on their nature.

He said such payments could be compensation or salary received in a capacity other than that of a shareholder.

The Duterte impeachment trial is set to resume on November 20.

The senator-judges have yet to finalize the December hearing schedule as the impeachment court prepares to make way for deliberations on the proposed 2027 national budget. – ANC, The World Tonight, November 19, 2026

Leave a Reply