Friday, November 20, 2026

Thinking Port

Another port for thinking people…

ABS-CBNNewsPhilippines

Tensions flare over Cale88 as prosecution, defense clash in Sara Duterte impeachment trial

Tensions flared between the prosecution and defense during the 45th day of Vice President Sara Duterte’s impeachment trial, as questions surrounding Cale88 Foods Corporation continued to draw scrutiny from senator-judges.

The exchanges began when prosecution counsel Atty. Erwin Matib brought up Duterte’s alleged fondness for tree-planting, noting that Cale88 had not undertaken similar initiatives, despite requirements that certain businesses plant trees in exchange for government incentives.

Defense counsel Atty. Justin Nicol Gular objected, calling the prosecution’s insinuations linking the issue to Cale88 misleading, malicious, and callous.

Meanwhile, Senate President and Senator-Judge Sherwin Gatchalian questioned why Cale88 went through the process of registering with the Board of Investments but did not apply for other incentives available to businesses, including VAT zero-rating.

DTI Undersecretary and BOI Managing Head Ceferino Rodolfo said Cale88 was export-oriented but admitted he did not know why the company had not applied for the VAT incentive.

Senator-Judge Imee Marcos, meanwhile, asked Rodolfo whether there was any indication that Cale88 was fictitious or had inflated its export figures.

Rodolfo said there was none.

Asked whether Cale88 was an implausible business model, Rodolfo said he could not make that determination, but noted that other companies had reported similar figures to the BOI.

The Vice President’s legal team also stressed that Cale88 was not directly part of the allegations concerning Duterte’s alleged unexplained wealth, as the company is owned by her husband, Manases Carpio.

However, defense spokesperson Atty. Michael Poa said it was important for their side to clarify the issue before the public and the senator-judges.

Poa maintained that the allegations against Cale88 had no basis and said the defense would present witnesses when the impeachment trial resumes in December to provide more detailed explanations about the company’s operations and earnings.

An official from the Food and Drug Administration also took the witness stand during Thursday’s proceedings.

The FDA confirmed that Cale88 was registered with the agency and presented photographs of its banana chip products.

The prosecution, however, argued that the company’s FDA registration and product photographs were not sufficient proof that it was a legitimate exporting business.

The impeachment trial is set to resume on December 1 after the defense informed the court that its witnesses would be unavailable on November 26 and 27. – ANC, The World Tonight, November 20, 2026

Leave a Reply