Friday, November 20, 2026

Thinking Port

Another port for thinking people…

ABS-CBNNewsPhilippines

Victims’ lawyers back closed-door testimony in Duterte ICC case, cites safety risks

The Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) aims to finalize its preliminary examination on issues on the Philippine drug war in 2020.

MANILA — Legal representatives for victims in the International Criminal Court case against former Philippine President Rodrigo Roa Duterte have backed a prosecution request for closed-door hearings and pseudonyms, arguing that standard courtroom protections are insufficient to shield witnesses and their families from harm.

In a public redacted filing dated Nov. 12, 2026, and signed on Nov. 19 in The Hague and Manila, the Common Legal Representatives of the Victims (CLRV) expressed full support for the prosecution’s Oct. 30 request for in-court protective and special measures.

“This demonstrates that the mere application of conventional protective measures does not necessarily eliminate the risk of identification… The protection of family members is consistent with the scope and purpose of article 68(1) of the Statute… The CLRV therefore support the Prosecution’s position11 that the combination of a pseudonym and closed session testimony is necessary to provide effective protection,” the document read.

The filing, signed by lawyers Gilbert Andres, Joel Butuyan, and Paolina Massidda notes that while ICC proceedings are generally open to the public, the court has a legal duty under the Rome Statute to safeguard the safety, well-being, dignity, and privacy of victims and witnesses.

According to the victims’ counsel, standard anonymity tools would fail to protect those testifying due to the broader information environment surrounding the case.

“This demonstrates that the mere application of conventional protective measures does not necessarily eliminate the risk of identification and reinforces the need to assess their practical effectiveness in light of the specific circumstances of the case,” the filing states.

To prevent the public from piecing together a witness’s identity through the details of their statements, the lawyers argued that closed sessions must be paired with pseudonyms.

“The pseudonym would prevent the formal identification of the witness in the proceedings, while closed session testimony would prevent the disclosure of the substantive and contextual details capable of revealing [REDACTED] identity,” the document reads.

The legal team pointed out that witness vulnerability must be evaluated against the ongoing activities of groups aligned with the former leader, noting that risks “must be assessed in light of the continuing presence and activities of individuals and networks supportive of the Accused, [REDACTED].”

Beyond the courtroom, the lawyers warned that the fallout from public identification would ripple through the witnesses’ personal lives and communities back home.

“In the close-knit communities and family-oriented social context of the Philippines, the consequences of identifying a witness may extend well beyond [REDACTED],” the lawyers wrote, adding that exposure could carry security implications for relatives.

They further warned that “in the prevailing political and social climate in the Philippines, [REDACTED] could expose [REDACTED] to a real risk of harm, intimidation and/or social ostracism.”

While acknowledging that sealing hearings from the public limits the transparency of the trial, the victims’ representatives maintained that the measures are strictly necessary and proportionate, and will not unfairly prejudice Duterte’s right to a fair trial.

Ultimately, the lawyers emphasized that the success of the court’s work hinges on whether those coming forward feel secure enough to speak.

“Ultimately, the effective administration of international criminal justice depends on victims and witnesses being able to participate in proceedings without fear of retaliation,” the filing stated.

          

Leave a Reply